Tavim Blog Open Tavim

Tavim · how it works

Can a pianist's signature be measured?

We wanted Tavim to play a score the way a great pianist would. Inventing a style failed. Measuring one worked.

Play the same Bach prelude twice, once by Glenn Gould and once by Arthur Rubinstein, and you know within two bars who is at the piano. The notes are identical. Something else is speaking. Can that something be taken from one performance and given to another?

Why we tried

A score played exactly as written sounds dead. Every notation program proves it. We wanted Tavim to play a score the way a person would.

Our first attempt was to invent styles: calm, lively, romantic, each a set of numbers chosen by hand. They sounded like a machine pretending. We concluded that we would lose if we tried to invent a performance. A performance has to come from a performer.

What made it possible

Tavim keeps the performance apart from the score. So for any recording we hold, on its own, everything the pianist added to the notes. Do that for one pianist across many pieces, and what stays constant is the pianist.

We measured 29 pianists over 1,109 recordings.

What a signature is made of

  1. Freedom of time: how far the player bends the beat.
  2. Range of loud and soft.
  3. Touch: whether notes are joined or separated.
  4. The melody: how far it stands in front of the accompaniment.

What we found

Where time bends belongs to the music: every pianist slows at the same cadences. How much belongs to the pianist.

Gould bends time 0.39 as much as the average pianist, within a dynamic range of 0.60, with every line at equal weight. Yiruma has the widest range of loud and soft, 1.24, with the melody far in front.

Rubinstein surprised us. We had named his style "Fiery & Wide". The measurements disagreed: his range of loud and soft is narrower than average. The warmth is in his touch and his singing top line. The style is now "Free & Warm".

A check that looks only at playing style tells the three apart 78 times in 100.

SignatureFreedom of timeRange of loud and softTouchMelody in front
Clear & Strict like Glenn Gould0.390.60a little joinedlines kept equal
Free & Warm like Arthur Rubinstein1.080.92joineda singing top line
Singing & Liquid like Yiruma1.091.24fully joinedfar in front

The average pianist is 1.00.

You are the judge

Three signatures are in Tavim: Clear & Strict, Free & Warm, Singing & Liquid. Give it any score and choose one.

Will Gould's manner suit a Chopin nocturne? Will Yiruma's suit Bach? We have our opinions. Listen, and form yours.

Try it on your own recording.Free during the beta.
Open Tavim